• Facebook
  • Linkedin
  • Youtube
  • CLIENT LOGIN
  • FORMS
  • OPEN A NEW ACCOUNT
Call us today: 1-866-7500-IRA(472)
American IRA
  • ABOUT US
    • OUR TEAM
    • TESTIMONIALS
    • CONTACT US
    • CAREERS
  • SELF-DIRECTED IRA/401K ACCOUNTS
    • SELF-DIRECTED IRA – TRADITIONAL IRA
    • SELF-DIRECTED ROTH IRA
    • SELF-DIRECTED SEP IRA
    • SELF-DIRECTED SOLO 401k
    • SELF-DIRECTED SIMPLE IRA
    • SELF-DIRECTED HSA – HEALTH SAVINGS ACCOUNT
    • SELF-DIRECTED COVERDELL EDUCATION SAVINGS ACCOUNT
  • INVESTING
    • SELF-DIRECTED IRA – REAL ESTATE IRA
    • SELF-DIRECTED IRA FOR PRIVATE LENDING/NOTES
    • SELF-DIRECTED IRA FOR PRECIOUS METALS
    • SELF-DIRECTED IRA FOR PRIVATE COMPANIES
    • SELF-DIRECTED IRA FOR TAX LIENS/DEEDS
    • SELF-DIRECTED IRA FOR SINGLE MEMBER IRA LLC
    • SELF-DIRECTED IRA FOR JOINT VENTURES AND PARTNERSHIPS
    • SELF-DIRECTED IRA FOR BROKERAGE ACCOUNTS
    • SELF-DIRECTED IRA FOR OTHER INVESTMENTS
  • FEES
  • EVENTS
  • RESOURCES
    • BLOG
    • ESSENTIAL GUIDE
    • SELF-DIRECTED IRA FUNDAMENTALS
    • SELF-DIRECTED IRA – HOW IT WORKS
    • FAQs
    • CALCULATORS
    • SELF-DIRECTED IRA PROHIBITED TRANSACTIONS
  • PROFESSIONALS
  • PODCAST
  • Menu
Blog - Latest News

Traditional Brokerage vs. Self-Directed IRA: Which One Fits Your Future?

September 10, 2024/in Brokerage Account, Self-Directed IRA /by Jim Hitt

Sign up for a traditional brokerage and you’ll find everything’s laid out for you. The ability to buy and sell stocks within an IRA. The ability to browse and research mutual funds. But what if your plans for retirement are a little more broad than that? What if you want to include more diverse assets within a retirement portfolio—say real estate, precious metals, and even private companies? For that, you’d need to turn to a Self-Directed IRA with a Self-Directed IRA administration firm. Let’s explain what it is—and how you can decide whether this fits your future.

What is the Traditional Approach vs. Self-Directed IRAs?

The traditional approach to retirement savings typically involves using a conventional IRA, which is managed by a financial institution. This institution will likely offer a predefined set of investment options. You’re not reinventing the wheel here. In fact, this is how most people invest.

Using a traditional broker, you deposit funds into an account with a financial institution, such as a bank or brokerage. The institution provides a range of investment options, including stocks, bonds, mutual funds, and exchange-traded funds (ETFs). The key advantages of this approach include simplicity (it’s easy to set up and manage), tax benefits (it’s an IRA, after all), and the ease of choosing through predefined options.

Using a Self-Directed IRA is different. After all, the traditional approach has its limitations, particularly in terms of investment flexibility. Investors are confined to the products offered by the institution, which may not include alternative investments such as real estate or private equity. If you work with a Self-Directed IRA administration firm, however, you’ll find that having a third-party custodian on the IRA can streamline the process of diversifying your portfolio. A Self-Directed IRA administration firm that supports transactions like real estate and precious metals means you’ll have the options to make those purchases in your account if you so choose. And that’s a lot more freedom than the typical retirement investor is used to.

Why Self-Directed Your IRA?

It depends on your goals. If you’re an astute real estate investor, for example, and you want to include real estate assets in your portfolio, there’s no choice. The Self-Directed IRA is clearly the superior option because that’s how you’ll be able to include real estate assets in your retirement portfolio.

If you’re a “set it and forget it” investor who prefers stocks, however, you may think that the traditional approach is the only option. But even here, you can use a Self-Directed IRA. For example, here at American IRA, we offer the ability to hold stock brokerage accounts in your Self-Directed IRA. So even if you like that kind of approach, you can always leave yourself the option of broadening your investment horizons, so to speak.

Ultimately, Self-Directed IRAs are about investing with more freedom. They’re also about using the full protections of retirement accounts so you can maximize the value of those investments. Imagine having real estate, for example, within a Roth IRA—a post-tax account that offers all sorts of flexibility when investing. This means that when it’s time to collect retirement distributions, you won’t have to pay additional tax on top of what you’ve already paid. That’s a way to secure a more stable retirement future.

Of course, everyone’s strategy is different.  Interested in learning more about Self-Directed IRAs?  Contact American IRA, LLC at 866-7500-IRA (472) for a free consultation.  Download our free guides or visit us online at www.AmericanIRA.com.

For more information call us today at 866-7500-IRA(472)

Tags: self-directed ira, Traditional Brokerage
Share this entry
  • Share on Facebook
  • Share on Linkedin
You might also like
Private Equity Investing Here’s What Life Can Look Like with a Well-Funded Self-Directed IRA
Self-Directed IRA Retirement Are Your Grown Kids Ruining Your Self-Directed IRA Retirement?
Using a Self-Directed IRA for Hard Money Lending
Maximizing Retirement: Alternative Investments in a Self-Directed IRA Buying a Business With Your Self-Directed IRA
Maximizing Retirement: Alternative Investments in a Self-Directed IRA Top 10 Reasons to Own a Self-Directed IRA
What are “Private” Investments in a Self-Directed IRA? Private Company Investing Within a Self-Directed IRA
Self-Directed IRA Questions to Ask Yourself Before Selecting a Self-Directed IRA
Maximizing Retirement: Alternative Investments in a Self-Directed IRA Alternative Investments in Self-Directed IRAs

Search

Subscribe to American IRA on YouTube

Subscribe to American IRA on YouTube

Have 15 Minutes?

Self-Directed IRAs can be complex. At American IRA we have 40 years of experience making the process easy for our customers. Give us 15 Minutes and we'll walk you through everything you need to know, with no obligation.

Schedule a CallOur Story
Kyle MoodyBusiness Development Manager
You'll speak with Kyle or another member of our experienced team.

Recent Posts

  • Top Retirement Accounts for High-Net-Worth Individuals: Smart Strategies to Maximize Wealth
  • SEP IRA vs. Solo 401(k): Which Is Best for Small Business Owners?
  • Roth IRA Conversion Strategies for High-Income Earners
  • 10 Common Self-Directed IRA Mistakes Investors Should Avoid
  • Why Use a Self-Directed IRA to Invest in Tax Liens?

Get started today!

1-866-7500-IRA(472)

Proudly Serving 50 States

Contact

5015 S Bur Oak Pl, Suite A
Sioux Falls, SD 57108
828-257-4949

  • Facebook
  • Linkedin
  • Youtube
/
© 2026 American IRA
DISCLAIMER American IRA, LLC, a South Dakota limited liability company, serves as a Third Party Administrator on behalf of the Custodian, New Vision Trust Company, a state chartered South Dakota Trust Company. As a Self-Directed IRA administrator we are a neutral third party. We do not make any recommendations to any person or entity associated with investments of any type (including financial representatives, investment promoters or companies, or employees, agents or representatives associated with these firms). We are not responsible for and are not bound by any statements, representations, warranties or agreements made by any such person or entity and do not provide any recommendation on the quality, profitability or reputability of any investment, individual or company. The terms "we" and "us" refer to American IRA, with an office located in Sioux Falls, SD.
The Ins and Outs of a Self-Directed IRA LLC Operating Agreement In Case You Missed It: Notes from September Investors’ RoundTable

Claim Your Free Guide to Self Directed IRAs

Claim Your Free Guide to Real Estate IRAs

Claim Your Free Guide to Private Lending

Download Our Essential Guide to Self-Directed IRAs!

Download Our FREE Essential Guide to Self-Directed IRAs!

At American IRA, we pride ourselves on our exceptional educational materials that cater to everyone from beginners to advanced investors.

Our Essential Guide to Self-Directed IRAs is a great resource whether you’re new to investing or looking for increased diversification for your existing Traditional IRA, Roth IRA, SEP, Solo 401(k), SIMPLE, Health Savings Account, or Coverdell Education Account.

Download Now

  • Why a Self-Directed IRA?
  • How it Works
  • Investing: Popular Options
  • Real Estate
  • Private Lending
  • Tax Liens
  • Single Member LLC (a.k.a. Checkbook IRA)
  • And much more!
Share This
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • LinkedIn

Talk to a SpecialistLet's Talk

Schedule a Call
Or call us free on
(866) 750-0472
Prefer email? Send us a message

Talk to a Specialist

Scroll to top